Community Discovery · WAXFEED

How does the way you discover music shape your relationship to the community around you?

Community Discovery
SH
Shadrack Annor
TA
Theodore Addo
NA
Nathan Amankwah

The same gap. A different domain.

The Proximity Index measures the gap between what communities produce and what discovery platforms surface to those communities. The Community Discovery lab developed it to study why BIPOC-led nonprofits and the communities they serve could not find each other despite producing exactly what those communities needed. The finding: the gap was not caused by a lack of output. It was caused by discovery infrastructure that was never built to close it.

The same gap exists in music. A city's artists are not invisible because they are doing poor work. They are invisible because streaming platforms were not built to surface music by proximity. They were built to surface music by engagement. Those are different things with different community outcomes.

Before streaming, you found music through people and places. A friend played something in the car. A local DJ dropped something unfamiliar in a set. Someone behind a record store counter put it on because they had sized you up and thought you needed to hear it. Those moments were not just about the music. They were about the network of people and places through which the music moved. That network was community infrastructure. Algorithmic platforms stripped it out.

WAXFEED is a therapeutic environment for the music domain. It surfaces music through proximity: what artists are building scenes in your city, what your social graph is listening to, what is being made by and for the community you belong to. This research program applies the Proximity Index to music and tests WAXFEED as the corresponding intervention.

What the evidence shows.

DeNora · Cambridge University Press · 2000 Music in Everyday Life Music is not merely a cultural product. It is a social technology people use to organize emotional states, coordinate action, and construct identity. How you find it is inseparable from what it does for you. Monograph Straw · Cultural Studies · 1991 Systems of Articulation, Logics of Change Local music scenes are not self-sustaining phenomena. They depend on specific discovery infrastructure: physical spaces, distribution networks, and social rituals. When that infrastructure breaks down, scenes dissolve. Journal Article Prey · Media, Culture & Society · 2018 Nothing Personal: Algorithmic Individuation on Music Streaming Platforms Spotify's recommendation system erases the social and collective dimensions of musical taste. It presents music as uniquely personal while concealing the social graph through which preferences actually form. Journal Article Granovetter · American Journal of Sociology · 1973 The Strength of Weak Ties Weak social ties are more effective than strong ties at bridging social clusters and transmitting novel information. Local scenes depend on weak tie networks for discovery. Streaming platforms optimize for strong ties or no social graph at all. Journal Article McPherson, Smith-Lovin, Cook · Annual Review of Sociology · 2001 Birds of a Feather: Homophily in Social Networks Shared musical taste is one of the most powerful homophily signals in social network formation. Pure taste-based recommendation reinforces existing clusters rather than building new ones. Geographic proximity breaks this pattern. Journal Article

The Proximity Index, applied to music.

The Proximity Index takes two inputs and produces a score. Input one: the music produced by or for a community, measured through local artist registries, venue booking records, local press, and community-maintained directories. Input two: what discovery platforms actually surface when queried with community-identity prompts. The gap between those two numbers is the Proximity Score. A high score means music made for your community is algorithmically invisible to you.

The methodology was validated through the MUSEOFRI pilot in the civic resource domain. This research program adapts it to music, validates it in the new domain, and uses it to compute Scene Proximity Scores for local music communities across five mid-size U.S. cities. The question is whether cities with stronger community-embedded discovery infrastructure show lower Proximity Scores than cities where algorithmic platforms dominate.

The second stage tests WAXFEED as a Proximity-reducing intervention: a 90-day controlled comparison against Spotify, with Proximity Scores computed at baseline, 45 days, and 90 days. The question is whether a platform designed from proximity produces measurably stronger community outcomes than one designed from engagement.

Research Collaborator

The music domain adaptation of the Proximity Index is being built from the sociology of music, algorithmic recommendation research, and community formation literature. If you work in music studies, social computing, or community psychology and want to contribute to the methodology, reach out.

Get in touch

The signal was always there. The platform hid it.

The existing literature establishes the structural claim: algorithmic music discovery conceals the social and geographic signal that once made music discovery an act of community formation. What it does not yet establish is the causal magnitude. How much does discovery mode actually predict community connection? And by how much can a platform built around proximity shift that outcome?

Those are the empirical questions this lab is building toward. The Providence baseline study, in development, will produce the first Proximity Scores for a defined local music scene. The controlled WAXFEED intervention will be the first test of whether proximity-based discovery produces measurably stronger community outcomes than algorithmic alternatives.

This research is early. The instruments are in development. If you are in a position to accelerate that development, whether through methodological expertise, community access, or institutional partnership, the most useful thing you can do is reach out.

Artist or Venue Partner

The Providence baseline study needs local artists and venues willing to participate in the scene infrastructure mapping. If you are building a local scene or running a venue and want to contribute to this research, we want to hear from you.

Get in touch

Community Research Partner

The Scene Infrastructure Index will eventually cover five mid-size U.S. cities. If you work with local music communities outside Providence and want to extend this research to your context, reach out.

Get in touch

WAXFEED.

WAXFEED is what music discovery looks like when it is designed from proximity rather than engagement. Where algorithmic platforms surface music by listening patterns, WAXFEED surfaces music by who you know and where you are. That is not a design preference. It is a direct response to what the Proximity Index finds in the music domain: the gap between what local artists produce and what streaming platforms surface to the communities those artists belong to.

Local artists, particularly artists from BIPOC and working-class communities, are not invisible because they are doing poor work. Their work exists. It does not reach the people it was made for. WAXFEED is built to test whether proximity-based discovery can actually close that gap. This lab tests whether it moves the score.

Explore WAXFEED

Advisor

Experience in music studies, community psychology, social computing, or algorithmic auditing. This research needs methodological grounding from people who have worked inside these systems.

Get in touch

Lab Partner

Organizations with existing relationships in local music ecosystems, arts funding, or music technology research. Funders, arts councils, and platform partners are the right fit here.

Get in touch

Network & Introductions

If you know a music researcher, arts funder, or scene organizer who should be aware of this work, a warm introduction is worth more than any cold outreach.

Get in touch